Air fryers earned a permanent spot on most kitchen counters because they crisp frozen food faster than a conventional oven and cook chicken thighs to better texture than most home cooks manage in a pan. But the gap between the best and worst units is wide, with cheaper models cooking unevenly and the best handling everything from salmon to brussels sprouts to a full sheet pan of fries. After cooking five test foods across five air fryers over two weeks, these five earned their counter space.
Quick comparison
| Air Fryer | Capacity | Type | Best fit | Standout feature |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ninja AF101 | 4 qt | Basket | Singles and couples | Quiet operation |
| Cosori 5.8 Qt | 5.8 qt | Basket | Small families | Preset menu |
| Cuisinart TOA-65 | Oven cavity | Oven style | Multi function cooks | Replaces toaster oven |
| Instant Vortex Plus | 6 qt | Basket | Families | Dishwasher safe basket |
| Philips Premium HD9270 | 4.1 qt | Basket | Even cooking purists | Twin TurboStar airflow |
Ninja AF101 - Best Compact Pick
Check current price on Amazon ->
The Ninja AF101 is the small footprint air fryer to beat for anyone cooking for one or two. The four quart ceramic coated basket fits about a pound of fries or four chicken thighs and the unit runs noticeably quieter than the larger Ninja models. Heat up takes under two minutes and the basket distributes heat evenly enough that food crisps without a halfway shake in most cases.
The controls are mechanical knobs rather than a touchscreen, which makes the unit faster to adjust mid cook and less likely to fail over years of use. We cooked frozen fries, chicken wings, and salmon back to back across an evening and the basket cleaned up with a quick rinse each time.
Trade off: small capacity means batch cooking for a family takes multiple rounds. The basket also has a hard plastic divider that limits the actual usable surface.
Best for: small kitchens and households cooking for one or two.
Cosori 5.8 Qt - Best Family Basket Unit
Check current price on Amazon ->
The Cosori 5.8 quart hits the sweet spot for a family of three to four, with a basket large enough for a full pound and a half of wings or six chicken thighs in a single pass. The preset menu covers eleven common foods with default time and temperature settings, which actually saves time compared with guessing each setting from scratch.
Crisp results matched the Ninja on fries and the Cosori cooked a full salmon fillet more evenly than the Ninja thanks to the larger basket. The nonstick coating held up across two weeks of daily use and the basket released food cleanly even with sticky marinades.
Trade off: the touchscreen controls can be unresponsive when fingers are slightly wet, and the unit takes more counter space than the Ninja.
Best for: families wanting a single basket cook for the whole table.
Cuisinart TOA-65 - Best Oven Style
Check current price on Amazon ->
The Cuisinart TOA-65 is an air fryer pretending to be a toaster oven, or a toaster oven pretending to be an air fryer, depending on your angle. The oven cavity fits a four pound chicken or a twelve inch pizza, and the air fry function delivers crisp results within a noticeable but acceptable gap from a dedicated basket unit. The bake, broil, and toast functions actually work, which lets the unit replace a toaster oven on the counter.
We cooked frozen fries, brussels sprouts, and salmon and the results across the rack were even after a halfway flip. The clear front lets you watch the cook without opening the door, which is useful for delicate items.
Trade off: bulky. This is the largest unit on the list and it commands serious counter space. Crisping on fries is slightly less aggressive than a basket fryer.
Best for: cooks who want one appliance for air frying and traditional small oven jobs.
Instant Vortex Plus - Best Easy Clean
Check current price on Amazon ->
The Instant Vortex Plus six quart is the cleanup winner of the basket category. The basket and crisper plate are both dishwasher safe and the design is simple enough that grease drains cleanly without pooling in awkward channels. Heat distribution across the basket is consistent and the unit cooks frozen fries in roughly fifteen minutes from cold.
The six quart capacity matches the Cosori and the touchscreen controls are responsive. We cooked back to back batches of wings and the unit held temperature without dropping noticeably between cooks.
Trade off: louder than the Ninja and slightly less polished in build quality than the Philips. The unit also takes a few seconds longer to reach temperature.
Best for: families who want a large basket unit that goes straight into the dishwasher.
Philips Premium HD9270 - Best Even Cooking
Check current price on Amazon ->
The Philips Premium HD9270 is the most consistently even cooking basket fryer tested. The twin TurboStar airflow design produces results that need fewer halfway flips than any other unit on the list, with fries crisp across the entire batch and chicken thighs browned evenly top and bottom. The fat removal tray catches drippings cleanly and keeps grease away from the heating element.
Build quality stands out. The basket lid clicks shut decisively and the unit feels solid rather than plastic-flimsy. We cooked a side by side batch of brussels sprouts against the Cosori and the Philips produced crisp leaves throughout the basket while the Cosori had a few softer pieces in the corners.
Trade off: most expensive on the list and the 4.1 quart capacity is small for the price.
Best for: cooks who prioritize even results over capacity.
How to choose the right air fryer
Size to your real cooking volume. Four quarts is plenty for one or two people. Five to six quarts is the family standard. Larger only makes sense for oven style units.
Basket for speed, oven for flexibility. Basket units crisp better and faster. Oven style units replace a toaster oven and bake, broil, and toast as well.
Cleanup is half the value. A dishwasher safe basket changes whether you actually use the unit daily. Coatings vary, so check whether the basket is dishwasher rated before buying.
Skip presets unless you really use them. The eleven preset menu is helpful for new owners but most cooks settle into manual time and temperature settings within a month. A reliable knob-based unit can be a better long term pick than a touchscreen.
For more kitchen picks, see our best cooking accessories roundup and the best cooking blender guide. Our full review approach is documented in our methodology.
The right air fryer crisps better than a conventional oven and uses a tiny fraction of the oil of a deep fryer. The Philips is the even-cook champion, the Cosori is the family default, the Ninja wins for small kitchens, the Cuisinart replaces a toaster oven, and the Instant Vortex is the easiest to clean.
Frequently asked questions
What size air fryer do I actually need?+
For one to two people, a four quart basket is enough for most weeknight meals. For three to four people, look at five to six quart baskets so you can cook a full batch of fries or chicken thighs in one pass. For larger families or anyone who wants to roast a whole small chicken, a toaster oven style unit with a six to ten quart cavity gives the flexibility. Buying too small is the most common regret, but buying too large means the unit takes counter space you cannot reclaim.
Do air fryers really replace a deep fryer for crispiness?+
Not exactly. A deep fryer fully submerges food in hot oil, which crisps every surface evenly. An air fryer uses fast hot air and a small amount of oil, which crisps the exposed surfaces well but leaves the side touching the basket softer unless you flip halfway through. For frozen foods like fries, nuggets, and wings, the air fryer gets within ninety percent of fryer results with a tiny fraction of the oil. For battered foods made from scratch, a real fryer still wins.
Are basket air fryers or oven style air fryers better?+
Basket air fryers cook small to medium batches faster and they crisp better because the air circulates more aggressively in a smaller chamber. Oven style units like the Cuisinart TOA-65 are more versatile because they also bake, toast, broil, and roast, which can replace a toaster oven and a small air fryer with a single appliance. Pick basket if speed and crisp are the priority, oven style if you want one machine that does more jobs.
How do I keep the basket from becoming a mess to clean?+
Line the basket with perforated parchment rounds for messy items like wings or fish, and never use solid foil because it blocks airflow. Most baskets are nonstick and dishwasher safe but hand washing extends the coating life. Wipe the basket while it is still slightly warm and food has not hardened. If the unit has removable trays and racks, take them out and soak in hot soapy water for fifteen minutes before scrubbing. Avoid metal utensils on the coating.
Is it safe to use an air fryer every day?+
Yes, air fryers are safe for daily use as long as the basket coating stays intact and you avoid heating empty for long periods. Check the basket monthly for chips or peeling and replace the basket or the whole unit if you see flaking. Standard non-stick coatings are stable up to four hundred Fahrenheit, which is within the operating range of all five units on this list. Daily users should also clean the fan housing and heating coil every couple of months.
Priya Sharma
Priya Sharma writes for The Tested Hub.