Classic Chocolate Chip Cookies -- Best Overall Santa Cookie
You can't go wrong with chocolate chip cookies for Santa. they're a strong crowd-pleaser and one of the easiest recipes to make with kids of any age. A classic recipe using browned butter takes only about 20 minutes of prep and produces thick, chewy cookies with golden edges that look genuinely impressive on Santa's plate. Kids can measure, mix, and scoop dough without much supervision, making the baking experience as memorable as the tradition itself. Leave two or three generous-sized cookies alongside a glass of cold milk and a small note. Pre-made chocolate chip cookie dough makes this even more accessible for families with limited time on Christmas Eve.
Check price on Amazon →The best cookies to leave for Santa in 2026. from classic chocolate chip to decorated sugar cookies. These festive picks are fun to bake and delicious enough for the big night.
Leaving cookies for Santa is one of the most beloved holiday traditions, and choosing the right cookie makes the night feel extra special. The best Santa cookies are fun for kids to help bake, look festive on the plate, and taste good enough that even the adults sneaking bites after bedtime will be satisfied. These five picks are tried-and-true favorites that never disappoint on Christmas Eve.
| Cookie Type | Kid-Friendliness | Festive Factor | Rating |
|—|—|—|—|
| Classic Chocolate Chip | Very High | Medium | 5/5 |
| Decorated Sugar Cookies | High | Very High | 4.8/5 |
| Snickerdoodle | High | Medium | 4.7/5 |
| Gingerbread Men | High | Very High | 4.6/5 |
| Peanut Butter Blossoms | Medium | Medium | 4.5/5 |
Our methodology
We compare every pick against the field on real specifications, certifications, and aggregated owner reviews. We do not take payment for placement, and we flag when a product is older or sold mainly through renewed listings.
Side by side
| Pick | Best for | Score | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Classic Chocolate Chip Cookies -- Best Overall Santa Cookie | Check price | ||
| Decorated Sugar Cookies -- Most Festive Choice | Check price | ||
| Snickerdoodles -- Best for a Cozy Classic Feel | Check price | ||
| Gingerbread Men -- Best Festive Tradition | Check price | ||
| Peanut Butter Blossoms -- Best for Peanut Butter Fans | Check price |
The full reviews
Classic Chocolate Chip Cookies -- Best Overall Santa Cookie
You can't go wrong with chocolate chip cookies for Santa. they're a strong crowd-pleaser and one of the easiest recipes to make with kids of any age. A classic recipe using browned butter takes only about 20 minutes of prep and produces thick, chewy cookies with golden edges that look genuinely impressive on Santa's plate. Kids can measure, mix, and scoop dough without much supervision, making the baking experience as memorable as the tradition itself. Leave two or three generous-sized cookies alongside a glass of cold milk and a small note. Pre-made chocolate chip cookie dough makes this even more accessible for families with limited time on Christmas Eve.
Decorated Sugar Cookies -- Most Festive Choice
Decorated sugar cookies. Cutout in Christmas tree, star, reindeer, and candy cane shapes, then iced with royal icing in red, green, and white. Are the most visually festive option for Santa's plate. The decoration process is a beloved activity for kids, and the finished cookies look like they belong in a holiday magazine spread. Use a firm rollout sugar cookie recipe (not the soft variety) so the shapes hold perfectly and the icing dries to a smooth, glossy finish. Premade royal icing in squeeze bottles makes decorating accessible even for small hands. The visual impact of a plate of beautifully iced cookies next to the Christmas tree is unmatched by any other option.
Snickerdoodles -- Best for a Cozy Classic Feel
Snickerdoodles bring a warm, cinnamon-sugar nostalgia to Santa's plate that feels quintessentially holiday. These soft, pillowy cookies rolled in cinnamon sugar before baking are approachable for even the youngest bakers and require no decoration or special equipment. The slight tang from cream of tartar gives snickerdoodles their distinctive flavor that sets them apart from generic sugar cookies. They bake up with crinkled tops and soft centers, and the cinnamon aroma that fills the house while they're baking is part of the magic. Leave a stack of four or five with a glass of milk for a simple, classic presentation that never feels underwhelming.
Gingerbread Men -- Best Festive Tradition
Gingerbread men are perhaps the most iconic of all Christmas cookies and make a delightful addition to Santa's plate, especially when kids have decorated them with icing smiles and button details. The warm spice blend of ginger, cinnamon, cloves, and molasses fills the kitchen with an unmistakably holiday aroma. Gingerbread dough is forgiving and fun to roll and cut, making it an excellent family baking project. Decorate with simple white royal icing dots and lines, or go all-out with candy decorations and colored icing. A gingerbread man on Santa's plate. especially one that a child baked and decorated themselves. adds a personal, heartfelt element that store-bought options can't replicate.
Peanut Butter Blossoms -- Best for Peanut Butter Fans
Peanut butter blossoms. soft peanut butter cookies topped with a Hershey's Milk Chocolate Kiss. are a holiday staple in many American households. They're easy to make, visually distinctive with the chocolate kiss centerpiece, and beloved by anyone who enjoys the peanut butter and chocolate combination. The cookies stay soft for days, which is useful if you're baking a day ahead. Press the chocolate kisses into the warm cookies immediately after baking so they meld slightly with the surface. Note that these are not suitable for households with nut allergies. For families without that concern, peanut butter blossoms add a fun, festive element to Santa's cookie plate and disappear quickly.
What matters most
What to consider
Let the kids have a say. the tradition is as much about their excitement as the cookies themselves. Chocolate chip and snickerdoodles are safest for mixed age groups and non-bakers. If you enjoy the decorating process as a family activity, sugar cookies and gingerbread men provide the most interactive experience. For families with nut allergies, skip the peanut butter blossoms entirely. Bake the night before to reduce Christmas Eve stress, and store cookies in an airtight container to keep them fresh.
What to consider
For more holiday cookie inspiration, see [/articles/best-cookies-for-gift-giving](/articles/best-cookies-for-gift-giving) and [/articles/best-cookies-for-shipping](/articles/best-cookies-for-shipping). Learn about our testing process at [/methodology](/methodology).
Frequently asked
Chocolate chip cookies are consistently the most popular choice for leaving out for Santa, according to surveys of American families. They're universally loved, easy to bake with kids, and require no special decoration. Sugar cookies decorated with red and green icing are a close second, especially popular with families who enjoy the decorating process as part of their holiday tradition.
Absolutely. Store-bought cookies are a perfectly fine choice for Santa's plate, especially in busy households. Premium options like Walkers shortbread tins, Pepperidge Farm Milano cookies, or decorated holiday sugar cookies from a local bakery are thoughtful choices that kids can still participate in selecting and arranging on the plate alongside the traditional glass of milk.