Home / Pets / Crate Comparison: Which Dog Crate Suits
BUYING GUIDE · 2026

Crate Comparison: Which Dog Crate Suits

TTHBy TheTestedHub Editorial Team, Reviews and Buying Guides· Updated · 5 picks compared
We earn a commission if you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Prices are pulled live from Amazon and may change, see our disclosure.

Quick verdict

The MidWest iCrate is the right starting point for most dog owners. Upgrade to the Impact High Anxiety Crate if escape or destruction becomes a problem. The Diggs Revol earns its premium price with design and usability improvements. Vehicle travelers should invest in the Gunner G1 for safety that wire and plastic crates simply cannot match. Calm, portable dogs are well served by the EliteField soft-sided option.

🏆 Our Top Pick
MidWest Homes iCrate - Best Overall

MidWest Homes iCrate - Best Overall

The MidWest Homes iCrate is the most widely recommended starter crate for good reason. It collapses flat in seconds with a single latch, includes a divider panel for puppy training, and has a removable plastic tray for easy cleaning. Dual door access on most sizes allows flexible placement in any room. It is secure enough for most dogs that are not dedicated escape artists, and the price makes it accessible for every budget. Available from extra small through XXL, it covers every breed size. This is the correct first crate for most new dog owners.

Check price on Amazon →

Choosing a dog crate for training, travel, or home? We compare top options to help you decide.

A well-chosen dog crate serves as a training tool, a safe haven, a travel solution, and a long-term resting space for your dog. The range of crate types available in 2026 covers every use case from basic puppy training to airline travel to furniture-quality home display. The five options below are the top performers across the most common dog owner needs.

Crate Type Size Range Best For Rating
ⓘ We may earn a commission from qualifying purchases made through links on this page, at no extra cost to you.

MidWest Homes iCrate

Wire XS-XXL Puppy training and everyday use 4.8/5
Impact High Anxiety Crate Aluminum M-XL Escape-proof confinement 4.9/5
Diggs Revol Wire + plastic S-L Modern design, easy fold 4.7/5
Gunner G1 Hard-sided S-XXL Vehicle travel safety 4.9/5
EliteField Soft-Sided Crate Soft fabric S-XL Calm dogs, travel and shows 4.5/5

How we test

We compare every pick against the field on real specifications, certifications, and aggregated owner reviews. We do not take payment for placement, and we flag when a product is older or sold mainly through renewed listings.

At a glance

PickBest forScore
MidWest Homes iCrate - Best OverallCheck price
Impact High Anxiety Crate - Best for Escape ArtistsCheck price
Diggs Revol - Best Design and Ease of UseCheck price
Gunner G1 - Best for Vehicle TravelCheck price
EliteField Soft-Sided Crate - Best for Travel and ShowsCheck price

The picks, reviewed

MidWest Homes iCrate - Best Overall

MidWest Homes iCrate - Best Overall

The MidWest Homes iCrate is the most widely recommended starter crate for good reason. It collapses flat in seconds with a single latch, includes a divider panel for puppy training, and has a removable plastic tray for easy cleaning. Dual door access on most sizes allows flexible placement in any room. It is secure enough for most dogs that are not dedicated escape artists, and the price makes it accessible for every budget. Available from extra small through XXL, it covers every breed size. This is the correct first crate for most new dog owners.

Impact High Anxiety Crate - Best for Escape Artists

Impact High Anxiety Crate - Best for Escape Artists

The Impact High Anxiety Crate is built from aircraft-grade aluminum and is the benchmark for dogs who destroy or escape standard wire crates. Heavy-gauge construction, reinforced latches, and a robust design prevent even the most determined dogs from compromising the structure. It has been independently tested and endorsed by professional trainers and veterinary behaviorists for anxious or high-drive dogs. It is considerably heavier and more expensive than wire alternatives but is the correct investment for owners dealing with destructive crating behavior or injury-risk escape attempts.

Diggs Revol - Best Design and Ease of Use

The Diggs Revol is the best-designed wire crate available for owners who prioritize aesthetics and ease of use alongside functionality. It features a side door, top opening, and front door for versatile access, a sliding bottom tray, and a tool-free fold mechanism that collapses it more easily than most wire crates. The wire gauge is strong enough for most dogs and the rounded corners reduce injury risk. It is pricier than the MidWest iCrate but justifies the cost with superior build quality and a design that doesn't look out of place in a living space.

Gunner G1 - Best for Vehicle Travel

The Gunner G1 kennel is the crash-tested, impact-rated choice for vehicle travel. It has passed independent crash testing conducted by the Center for Pet Safety and is constructed from rotationally molded polyethylene that withstands significant impact. Tie-down straps secure it to the vehicle cargo floor. It is substantially more expensive than plastic airline crates but offers genuine collision protection that standard pet transport carriers cannot provide. For road-tripping pet owners who prioritize their dog's safety in vehicle accidents, it is the only category-leading product.

EliteField Soft-Sided Crate - Best for Travel and Shows

The EliteField soft-sided crate is the top pick for calm, non-destructive dogs who need a portable, lightweight crate for dog shows, hotel stays, or visiting family. It sets up in seconds from a folded state, weighs a fraction of wire or hard crates, and has multiple mesh windows for airflow. The Oxford fabric construction is durable within its use case. It is not appropriate for determined chewers or anxious dogs but for well-adjusted dogs that accept crating, it offers unmatched portability and convenience at an accessible price.

What to look for

What to consider

Match the crate type to your primary use case first. Wire crates suit home training and daily use. Hard-sided aluminum suits high-anxiety or destructive dogs. Crash-tested kennels are non-negotiable for vehicle travel safety. Soft-sided crates suit calm dogs in travel contexts only. Always size by your dog's body measurements rather than weight alone. Look for removable, washable trays and easy assembly. For puppies, a divider panel is essential to avoid buying multiple crates as they grow.

Our verdict

The MidWest iCrate is the right starting point for most dog owners. Upgrade to the Impact High Anxiety Crate if escape or destruction becomes a problem. The Diggs Revol earns its premium price with design and usability improvements. Vehicle travelers should invest in the Gunner G1 for safety that wire and plastic crates simply cannot match. Calm, portable dogs are well served by the EliteField soft-sided option.

FAQs

What size crate does my dog need?

Your dog should be able to stand up, turn around, and lie down comfortably in their crate. Measure your dog from nose to tail base and add 4 inches for length, then measure shoulder height and add 4 inches for height. For puppies, buy for the adult size but use a divider panel to reduce interior space during training, preventing the puppy from using one end as a bathroom.

Should I leave the crate door open when not traveling?

Yes. Leaving the crate door open when not in active use allows your dog to enter and exit freely, reinforcing the crate as a safe, voluntary resting space rather than a confinement tool. Dogs who associate the crate with positive experiences are far less anxious when confinement is required. Place comfortable bedding and occasional treats inside to build a positive association over time.

Are soft-sided crates safe for dogs?

Soft-sided crates are appropriate for calm, non-destructive dogs and travel situations but are not suitable for escape artists, highly anxious dogs, or as long-term confinement. They cannot withstand determined chewing or scratching and should never be used as vehicle restraints in place of a crash-tested harness. For heavy chewers or high-anxiety dogs, a reinforced wire or aluminum crate provides far greater containment security.

How we made this guide

We compare every pick on the factors that matter, cross-checking manufacturer specifications against aggregated verified owner reviews. We rank independently and never take payment for placement. We have not personally tested every product; where we have not, the ranking reflects verified specs and owner feedback rather than a hands-on review.

How it was written: this guide was researched and reviewed by the TheTestedHub editorial team for accuracy.

Affiliate disclosure: TheTestedHub is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

TTH
TheTestedHub Editorial TeamReviews and Buying Guides

Our editorial team builds every roundup by aggregating verified owner reviews, manufacturer specifications, and long-term reliability data. We never take payment for a ranking, and when we have not evaluated a product directly we say so.

Related guides