Quick verdict
The Rinehart 18-1 is the best all-around broadhead target for crossbow use - it handles every tip type, lasts longer than any comparable product, and makes bolt removal manageable. Budget-conscious hunters should start with the Block Classic, which delivers reliable performance at half the price. Whichever you choose, using a broadhead-rated target protects your equipment, your arrows, and your safety at the range.
Rinehart 18-1 - The Multi-Target Classic
Rinehart's 18-1 is a benchmark for broadhead-rated targets. Its self-healing solid foam construction accepts fixed broadheads, mechanicals, and field points interchangeably - you can switch between tip types without rotating to a new face. The 18 different shooting positions extend target life dramatically, and the open-cell foam design makes bolt removal far easier than compressed-layer alternatives. For serious pre-season practice with hunting setups, nothing beats it.
Check price on Amazon →Broadheads slice through standard targets in seconds. These five picks are purpose-built to stop fixed and mechanical blades cleanly, protect your bolts, and last through a full season of hunting prep.
Shooting broadheads into a target not rated for them is one of the fastest ways to destroy both the target and your bolts. The blades cut rather than compress, creating locked-in penetration that tears foam apart on removal. The five targets below are specifically engineered for broadhead use – they stop blades cleanly, allow reasonable bolt removal, and hold up over hundreds of shots so you arrive at hunting season with sharp edges and dialed-in aim.
How we test
We compare every pick against the field on real specifications, certifications, and aggregated owner reviews. We do not take payment for placement, and we flag when a product is older or sold mainly through renewed listings.
At a glance
| Pick | Best for | Score | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rinehart 18-1 - The Multi-Target Classic | Check price | ||
| Block Classic - Affordable All-Season Broadhead Block | Check price | ||
| Morrell Yellow Jacket Supreme - High-Volume Bag Target | Check price | ||
| Field Logic Block Vault - High-Speed Broadhead Stopper | Check price | ||
| GlenDel Buck - Full-Size 3D Broadhead Practice | Check price |
The picks, reviewed
Rinehart 18-1 - The Multi-Target Classic
Rinehart's 18-1 is a benchmark for broadhead-rated targets. Its self-healing solid foam construction accepts fixed broadheads, mechanicals, and field points interchangeably - you can switch between tip types without rotating to a new face. The 18 different shooting positions extend target life dramatically, and the open-cell foam design makes bolt removal far easier than compressed-layer alternatives. For serious pre-season practice with hunting setups, nothing beats it.
Block Classic - Affordable All-Season Broadhead Block
The Field Logic Block Classic has earned its reputation through sheer consistency. Its compressed-foam construction provides reliable stopping power for crossbow bolts tipped with fixed-blade broadheads up to 125 grains, and the four shootable sides give you plenty of surface area before one face wears out. The bright yellow and black target face is easy to see at 40+ yards. If you want a no-fuss, affordable block that handles broadheads reliably, this is the smart starting point.
Morrell Yellow Jacket Supreme - High-Volume Bag Target
Morrell's Yellow Jacket Supreme stands out in the bag-target category as one of the few designs genuinely rated for broadhead use. The internal fill is a tightly packed synthetic fiber blend that catches blades without cutting around them. It's lighter and more portable than foam block alternatives, making it ideal for field setups or range days where you're moving targets around. Expected bolt removal effort is higher than self-healing foam, but the price-to-shots ratio is excellent.
Field Logic Block Vault - High-Speed Broadhead Stopper
The Block Vault earns a second mention here because it sits at the intersection of high-fps and broadhead compatibility - a rare combination. Its polyfusion foam layers handle both fixed and mechanical broadheads at crossbow velocities, and the self-contained block design means there's no frame to work around. If you're shooting a fast crossbow with hunting-weight broadheads, the Block Vault covers both requirements in one purchase.
GlenDel Buck - Full-Size 3D Broadhead Practice
The GlenDel Buck is the top choice for hunters who want their practice to mirror their hunt as closely as possible. The replaceable four-sided insert absorbs broadhead strikes directly in the vital zone, protecting the outer body from wear and saving money long-term. GlenDel's open-cell foam insert grips broadheads firmly on impact but releases them with reasonable effort on removal. Training on a life-size deer silhouette with your actual hunting broadheads removes guesswork on opening morning.
What to look for
Explicit broadhead rating
A target must be labeled broadhead-compatible - do not assume. Products that only list field-point use will fail quickly and dangerously with broadheads.
Fixed vs. mechanical compatibility
Fixed-blade heads require foam that closes tightly around a blade profile. Mechanical heads additionally stress the target on deployment impact. Confirm the target handles whichever style you hunt with.
Self-healing foam vs. bag fill
Self-healing foam (Rinehart, Field Logic) lasts longer and removes easier. Bag fill (Morrell) is more portable and affordable per session but removal requires more effort.
Replaceable cores
For 3D targets especially, a replaceable vital insert is worth the premium - it avoids buying a whole new target when the kill zone wears out.
Bolt removal effort
High-density targets that stop fast bolts tend to grip harder. If ease of removal matters, lean toward self-healing foam or open-cell designs.
Our verdict
The Rinehart 18-1 is the best all-around broadhead target for crossbow use - it handles every tip type, lasts longer than any comparable product, and makes bolt removal manageable. Budget-conscious hunters should start with the Block Classic, which delivers reliable performance at half the price. Whichever you choose, using a broadhead-rated target protects your equipment, your arrows, and your safety at the range.
FAQs
Standard bag and layered foam targets use materials that broadhead blades cut rather than compress through. The blades slice clean channels on entry, then catch on the return trip - either locking your bolt inside or tearing the target apart. Broadhead-rated targets use self-healing foam or specially bonded foam layers that close around blades for controlled stopping.
Yes, but check the specific product. Targets like the Rinehart 18-1 and Block Classic are rated for both fixed and mechanical broadheads. Some foam targets close well around fixed blades but get shredded by large-diameter expandables. If you shoot 2-inch cut mechanicals, confirm the target is rated for them before buying.
Rotate the bolt a quarter-turn as you pull - this breaks the foam's grip on the blades without tearing the target. Some shooters use a bolt-removal tool for consistent extraction. Never yank straight back, as this damages both the target and can bend or nick the broadhead blades.
Related guides
5 Best Crossbow Slings of 2026 | Carry Comfortably All Day
5 Best Crossbow Targets for 450 fps of 2026 | Heavy-Duty Stopping Power
5 Best Crossbow Targets for Over 400 FPS of 2026 | Heavy-Duty Picks
5 Best Crossbow Targets for 500 FPS of 2026 | Ultra-Heavy-Duty Picks
5 Best Crossbow Bolts for CenterPoint Sniper 370 2026 | Compatible Picks
5 Best Crossbow Backpacks of 2026 | Bags & Carrying Cases
5 Best Crossbow Targets for 400 fps of 2026 | Tested at Full Speed
