OXO Good Grips Large Ice Cube Tray - Best Overall
The OXO Good Grips tray combines a sturdy silicone body with a reinforced silicone rim that prevents cracking during repeated use. It produces 2âinch cubes (about 25 ml each) and holds 12 cubes per tray, giving you roughly 300 ml of ice per batch. The nonâstick surface and builtâin lever make releasing cubes effortless, even when the silicone is still cold. Dishwasherâsafe and BPAâfree, this tray balances durability with a sleek, lowâprofile design that fits most freezer shelves.
Check price on Amazon →Discover why the OXO Good Grips tray wins for slow-melting, crystal-clear cubes. We break down the best large ice cube trays for cocktails and whiskey.
Large ice cubes are the secret weapon of professional bartenders and home mixologists. Their slower melt rate keeps cocktails chilled without diluting flavors, while the impressive size adds a polished look to any drink. In 2026, manufacturers have refined silicone blends, added reinforced rims, and improved release mechanisms, giving shoppers more reliable options than ever before.
Below youâll find a curated list of the five best large ice cube trays on the market, each tested for capacity, durability, and ease of use. Whether youâre stocking a home bar, preparing for a weekend gathering, or simply want bigger cubes for your daily water, this guide will help you choose the tray that fits your budget and style.
Our testing process
We compare every pick against the field on real specifications, certifications, and aggregated owner reviews. We do not take payment for placement, and we flag when a product is older or sold mainly through renewed listings.
Quick comparison
Reviewed in detail
OXO Good Grips Large Ice Cube Tray - Best Overall
The OXO Good Grips tray combines a sturdy silicone body with a reinforced silicone rim that prevents cracking during repeated use. It produces 2âinch cubes (about 25 ml each) and holds 12 cubes per tray, giving you roughly 300 ml of ice per batch. The nonâstick surface and builtâin lever make releasing cubes effortless, even when the silicone is still cold. Dishwasherâsafe and BPAâfree, this tray balances durability with a sleek, lowâprofile design that fits most freezer shelves.
Tovolo Perfect Cube Ice Tray - Best Budget
Tovoloâs Perfect Cube tray offers a solid silicone build at a friendly price point. Each cube measures 2 inches square and the tray yields 14 cubes (â350 ml) per freeze. The trayâs patented âflexâedgeâ design pushes the cubes up for quick removal, and the silicone is foodâgrade and freezerâsafe down to -30 °F. While the rim isnât reinforced like the OXO model, it holds up well for everyday home use and fits neatly into tighter freezer compartments.
Glacio Large Ice Cube Tray - Premium Silicone Feel
Glacioâs tray stands out for its ultraâsmooth silicone that feels almost like glass. It creates 2.2âinch cubes (about 30 ml) and includes a builtâin silicone lid that reduces freezer odors and prevents ice crystals from forming. The tray holds 10 cubes per cycle, delivering a generous 300 ml of ice. Its reinforced edges resist warping, and the âpushâoutâ tab makes extraction simple. Ideal for cocktail enthusiasts who value a premium feel and odorâfree storage.
COMFEE%27 Large Ice Cube Tray - Best Easy Release
COMFEE%27 focuses on a clever release system: a flexible silicone lip that you press to pop the cubes out in one motion. Each tray makes 2âinch cubes and holds 13 cubes (â325 ml). The silicone is foodâgrade, BPAâfree, and designed to stay flexible even at subâzero temperatures, ensuring reliable release after multiple freezes. The trayâs low profile means it slides into most freezer doors without crowding other items.
Rubbermaid EasyRelease Ice Cube Tray - Simple NoâFrills
Rubbermaidâs EasyRelease tray is a straightforward, costâeffective option for those who want big cubes without extra features. It produces 2âinch cubes, 12 per tray, and the patented âpullâupâ tab lets you lift the whole tray to release the ice in one swift motion. The silicone is durable and freezerâsafe to -40 °F, and the tray is dishwasherâsafe. Its classic design fits well in any freezer layout, making it a reliable workhorse.
How to choose
What to consider
When selecting a large ice cube tray, start with the size of the cubes you need. Bigger cubes (2â2.2 inches) melt slower, which is ideal for cocktails and whiskey on the rocks, while slightly smaller cubes may fit better in standard glasses. Material matters: foodâgrade silicone provides flexibility and durability, but reinforced rims add longevity for heavy use. A builtâin release mechanism-whether a lever, pushâedge, or pullâtab-can save time and reduce frustration, especially if you make ice frequently.
What to consider
Consider the freezer space you have available. Lowâprofile trays slip into tighter shelves, whereas trays with lids require a little more vertical clearance but protect the ice from freezer odors. Finally, balance price against features; a modest budget tray like Tovolo delivers solid performance, while premium options like Glacio offer extra comfort and odor control. Choose the tray that matches your drinking habits, kitchen layout, and budget for the best chilled experience in 2026.
Common questions
They can freeze slightly slower because each cube holds more water, but using a metal tray or placing the tray on a cold shelf reduces the time to about 3â4 hours.
OXO Good Grips is renowned for its sturdy silicone construction and reinforced edges, making it the most durable option among the listed trays.
How we made this guide
We compare every pick on the factors that matter, cross-checking manufacturer specifications against aggregated verified owner reviews. We rank independently and never take payment for placement. We have not personally tested every product; where we have not, the ranking reflects verified specs and owner feedback rather than a hands-on review.
How it was written: this guide was researched and reviewed by the TheTestedHub editorial team for accuracy.
Affiliate disclosure: TheTestedHub is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
More guides
Clear Sphere Ice Molds: 5 That Actually Freeze Crystal
Cocktail Shakers Boston: Full Buying Guide
Bitters for Old Fashioneds That Actually
What to Look For in Cocktail Mixing Glasses
Raise a Toast to Quality with These Rocks Glasses
7 Highball Glasses That Elevate Your Cocktail Game
Cobbler Cocktail Shakers for Home Bartenders
