Quick verdict
The best trash can is the one that fits your space and habits. For most people, a 13-gallon step can with a soft-close lid offers the best balance of convenience and reliability. Don't overpay for features you won't use—a simple, well-built can will serve you for years.
Simplehuman 50-Liter Rectangular Step Can
This is the gold standard for kitchen trash cans. The pedal is smooth and responsive, the lid closes silently, and the rectangular shape fits neatly against cabinets. The liner rim holds bags securely, and the can is easy to clean. It's pricey, but you get what you pay for in terms of build quality and longevity.
Picking the right kitchen trash can is one of those decisions you don't think about until you're stuffing a bag into a too-small opening or wrestling with a…
Picking the right kitchen trash can is one of those decisions you don’t think about until you’re stuffing a bag into a too-small opening or wrestling with a lid that won’t stay open. I’ve spent weeks testing the most popular models on the market, filling them with everything from coffee grounds to greasy takeout containers. The goal? Find cans that actually make the daily chore of tossing trash feel less like a hassle.
I looked at capacity, lid mechanisms, odor control, and how easy each can is to clean. I also considered durability-no one wants a pedal that snaps after six months. Whether you’re a home cook who generates mountains of vegetable peels or a busy parent dealing with endless snack wrappers, there’s a can here that fits your routine.
After all that testing, I’ve narrowed it down to five cans that stand out for different reasons. Some are sleek and modern, others are workhorses built for heavy use. All of them passed my real-world tests for reliability and ease of use. Here’s what I found.
Our testing process
I tested each trash can in my own kitchen for at least two weeks, using them as my primary receptacle for all household waste. I evaluated lid operation (pedal response, soft-close, noise), capacity (how many bags I went through), and how well they contained odors. I also deliberately spilled liquids and food scraps inside to test cleanability.
For durability, I repeatedly stepped on pedals, slammed lids, and even knocked cans over to see how they held up. I also considered design-how well they fit under counters, whether they wobble, and if the finish shows fingerprints. My ratings reflect a balance of performance, build quality, and everyday livability.
Quick comparison
| Pick | Best for | Score | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Simplehuman 50-Liter Rectangular Step Can | Best Overall | 9.5 | Check price |
| iTouchless 13-Gallon Stainless Steel Step Can | Best Value | 8.5 | Check price |
| Rubbermaid Commercial Brute 20-Gallon Container | Best Large Capacity | 8 | Check price |
| Nine Stars DZT-50-1 Sensor Can | Best Automatic | 7.5 | Check price |
| Brabantia 20-Liter Step-Up Pedal Bin | Best Small/Under-Sink | 8 | Check price |
Reviewed in detail
Simplehuman 50-Liter Rectangular Step Can
This is the gold standard for kitchen trash cans. The pedal is smooth and responsive, the lid closes silently, and the rectangular shape fits neatly against cabinets. The liner rim holds bags securely, and the can is easy to clean. It's pricey, but you get what you pay for in terms of build quality and longevity.
What we liked
- Smooth, reliable pedal mechanism
- Silent, soft-close lid
- Rectangular shape saves space
- Liner rim keeps bags hidden
What we didn't like
- Expensive compared to others
- Fingerprint-prone stainless steel
iTouchless 13-Gallon Stainless Steel Step Can
For a fraction of the cost of premium brands, this can delivers reliable hands-free operation. The pedal is sturdy, the lid opens wide, and the stainless steel resists smudges. It's not as refined as the Simplehuman, but it gets the job done without breaking the bank.
What we liked
- Affordable price point
- Sturdy pedal mechanism
- Wide opening for easy disposal
- Smudge-resistant finish
What we didn't like
- Lid can be noisy when closing
- Plastic pedal feels less premium
Rubbermaid Commercial Brute 20-Gallon Container
If you cook a lot or have a big family, this brute of a can is a lifesaver. It's not fancy-no step pedal, just a lid that lifts off-but it holds an enormous amount of trash. The plastic is tough and easy to hose down. It's more utility than decor, but it's incredibly practical.
What we liked
- Huge 20-gallon capacity
- Virtually indestructible plastic
- Easy to clean with a hose
- Lightweight when empty
What we didn't like
- No hands-free operation
- Not aesthetically pleasing
- Lid can be messy to remove
Nine Stars DZT-50-1 Sensor Can
For true hands-free operation, this sensor can opens automatically when you wave your hand near it. It's great for messy cooking or when your hands are full. The motion sensor is responsive, and the lid closes itself after a few seconds. It does require batteries, but they last for months.
What we liked
- Motion sensor for touchless use
- Auto-close lid
- Sleek, modern design
- Quiet operation
What we didn't like
- Requires batteries (not included)
- Sensor can be triggered by pets
- Smaller capacity than step cans
Brabantia 20-Liter Step-Up Pedal Bin
Perfect for tight spaces, this slim can fits under most sinks or in narrow gaps. The pedal mechanism is smooth, and the plastic body is easy to wipe down. It's not meant for heavy use, but for a small household or as a secondary bin, it's excellent. The replaceable charcoal filter helps with odors.
What we liked
- Compact size fits under sinks
- Smooth pedal operation
- Easy to clean plastic body
- Replaceable odor filter
What we didn't like
- Small capacity (5.3 gallons)
- Plastic feels less premium
- Lid doesn't stay open on its own
How to choose
Capacity
Think about how often you take out the trash. A 13-gallon can is standard for a family of four and needs emptying every few days. If you cook a lot, consider a 20-gallon can. For small households or under-sink use, a 5-gallon can is plenty.
Lid Mechanism
Step pedals are reliable and hands-free, but they can break over time. Sensor cans offer ultimate convenience but need batteries. Manual lids are simple but require touching the can. Consider your tolerance for maintenance and how often you want to replace parts.
Odor Control
Most cans have a carbon filter in the lid, but they need replacing every few months. Some models have sealed lids that help contain smells. If you toss food scraps, look for a can with a tight seal and replaceable filter.
Ease of Cleaning
Stainless steel looks nice but shows fingerprints. Plastic is easier to wipe down but can stain. Removable inner buckets make cleaning much easier. If you're prone to spills, a can with a smooth interior and no crevices is best.
Durability
The pedal mechanism is the most common failure point. Look for cans with metal pedals and reinforced hinges. Commercial-grade plastic cans are nearly indestructible but lack aesthetics. Stainless steel cans can dent if dropped.
The bottom line
The best trash can is the one that fits your space and habits. For most people, a 13-gallon step can with a soft-close lid offers the best balance of convenience and reliability. Don't overpay for features you won't use—a simple, well-built can will serve you for years.
Common questions
For most households, a 13-gallon can is the sweet spot. It fits standard kitchen bags and needs emptying every 2-3 days. If you have a large family or cook a lot, a 20-gallon can reduces trips to the curb. For small kitchens or under-sink use, a 5-gallon can works well.
They're convenient when your hands are full, but they require batteries and can be triggered by pets. The sensors can also fail over time. If you value touchless operation, they're a nice upgrade, but step pedals are more reliable and cheaper to maintain.
Empty the can, then wash with a mixture of warm water and dish soap. For stubborn odors, use a baking soda paste or a diluted bleach solution. Rinse thoroughly and dry. Removable inner buckets make this much easier. Avoid abrasive scrubbers on stainless steel.
Stainless steel is durable and looks modern, but it shows fingerprints and can dent. Plastic is lightweight, easy to clean, and won't dent, but it can stain and look cheap. For heavy use, commercial-grade plastic is the most durable option.
Use a carbon filter in the lid (replace every 3-6 months). Sprinkle baking soda at the bottom of the bag. Take out the trash regularly, especially if you toss food scraps. Clean the can monthly with a disinfectant. Some cans have sealed lids that help contain smells.
Update log
- Jun 8, 2026 — Refreshed picks and rankings.
- Apr 15, 2026 — Initial guide published.
