Valuetoner Remanufactured Canon PG-245XL/CL-246XL - Best Overall Value
The Valuetoner combo pack is a standout choice for households and small offices that print frequently. These remanufactured cartridges are built from original Canon shells, refilled with high-quality ink, and fitted with reset chips that communicate properly with the printer. Print quality on documents and photos is sharp, and colors remain vibrant across hundreds of pages. The XL capacity makes each pack stretch further than standard options. Installation is straightforward with no additional driver downloads required. Page yield is reported at around 300 pages for color and 400 for black, making the per-page cost extremely competitive.
Check price on Amazon →Top compatible ink cartridges for Canon PIXMA printers that deliver sharp, vibrant prints at a fraction of OEM prices, with reliable yields and easy installation.
Replacing Canon PIXMA ink cartridges with OEM options adds up fast. Compatible cartridges solve that problem by offering the same reliable output at 50 to 70 percent lower cost. The five picks below have been selected based on verified page yields, chip compatibility, and consistent color accuracy reported by verified buyers.
| Product | Best For | Rating |
| — | — | — |
| Valuetoner Remanufactured Canon PG-245XL/CL-246XL | High-volume color printing | 4.5/5 |
| LD Products Canon PGI-280/CLI-281 | PIXMA TR/TS series | 4.4/5 |
| Ink & Toner Store Canon CLI-251XL | Photo printing | 4.3/5 |
| CompAndSave Canon PG-240XL/CL-241XL | Budget home printing | 4.2/5 |
| OfficeWorld Canon PG-243/CL-244 | Light-duty office use | 4.1/5 |
How we picked
We compare every pick against the field on real specifications, certifications, and aggregated owner reviews. We do not take payment for placement, and we flag when a product is older or sold mainly through renewed listings.
Top picks compared
| Pick | Best for | Score | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Valuetoner Remanufactured Canon PG-245XL/CL-246XL - Best Overall Value | Check price | ||
| LD Products Canon PGI-280/CLI-281 - Best for PIXMA TR and TS Series | Check price | ||
| Ink & Toner Store Canon CLI-251XL - Best for Photo Printing | Check price | ||
| CompAndSave Canon PG-240XL/CL-241XL - Best Budget Pick | Check price | ||
| OfficeWorld Canon PG-243/CL-244 - Best for Light Use | Check price |
Our picks up close
Valuetoner Remanufactured Canon PG-245XL/CL-246XL - Best Overall Value
The Valuetoner combo pack is a standout choice for households and small offices that print frequently. These remanufactured cartridges are built from original Canon shells, refilled with high-quality ink, and fitted with reset chips that communicate properly with the printer. Print quality on documents and photos is sharp, and colors remain vibrant across hundreds of pages. The XL capacity makes each pack stretch further than standard options. Installation is straightforward with no additional driver downloads required. Page yield is reported at around 300 pages for color and 400 for black, making the per-page cost extremely competitive.
LD Products Canon PGI-280/CLI-281 - Best for PIXMA TR and TS Series
LD Products has built a reputation as one of the more reliable third-party cartridge suppliers in North America. Their PGI-280/CLI-281 multipack is specifically tuned for the PIXMA TR8520, TR8620, TS6120, and related models. The pigment black ink delivers crisp text output, and the dye-based color inks produce accurate skin tones and landscape colors. Each cartridge includes an updated chip designed to prevent low-ink warnings from triggering too early. Customer reviews consistently highlight that print quality is difficult to distinguish from genuine Canon cartridges. A five-piece combo pack offers solid savings per page.
Ink & Toner Store Canon CLI-251XL - Best for Photo Printing
For users who print photos regularly, the Ink & Toner Store CLI-251XL delivers color accuracy that rivals more expensive options. The dye-based inks are formulated for smooth color gradients, and the XL capacity ensures you get more prints per replacement cycle. This cartridge fits a wide range of PIXMA MG and MX series printers. Users report minimal banding and good resistance to fading on photo paper. The packaging is solid with individual sealed bags to prevent drying before use. If photo output is your priority and you want to keep costs manageable, this is the cartridge to consider.
CompAndSave Canon PG-240XL/CL-241XL - Best Budget Pick
CompAndSave has been supplying compatible cartridges for years and their PG-240XL/CL-241XL combo is a reliable budget option for everyday home printing. Print quality on standard documents is clear and consistent, and the color cartridge handles basic graphics and school project printing without issue. The per-cartridge price is among the lowest available from an established supplier. While the photo output is not as refined as premium options, for text documents and general household use it performs well above expectations for the price. Compatible with the PIXMA MG2420, MG2520, MG3022, and related models.
OfficeWorld Canon PG-243/CL-244 - Best for Light Use
The OfficeWorld standard-capacity set is ideal for occasional printers who do not need XL yields. These cartridges install and run without printer errors and maintain consistent print quality through the entire ink supply. The lower upfront price makes them a sensible choice if you print infrequently and want to avoid ink drying out before you finish a cartridge. The black ink is clean and dark on plain paper, and the color output is accurate enough for everyday documents and occasional photos. Compatible with PIXMA MG2420, MG2522, MG2525, and several TS-series models.
Before you buy
What to consider
The most important step is confirming your exact printer model number, which appears on a sticker on the front or bottom of the printer. Each PIXMA model uses specific cartridge numbers, and mixing them up will result in incompatibility. Once you have the model number, look for cartridges from suppliers who publish ISO page yield data and offer a satisfaction guarantee or replacement policy. Remanufactured cartridges use original shells and are generally more environmentally responsible than fully synthetic options. XL capacity versions lower the per-page cost significantly if you print more than 50 pages a month. Avoid extremely cheap no-name packs without reviews, as these carry a higher risk of leaking or clogging print heads.
What to consider
For more office printing guidance, see our picks for [best all-in-one printers](/articles/best-all-in-one-printers) and [best wireless printers for home offices](/articles/best-wireless-printers-for-home-office). You can also review how we evaluate products at [/methodology](/methodology).
Quick answers
Yes, quality compatible cartridges are engineered to meet or exceed OEM specifications. Look for ISO-certified manufacturers and cartridges with chip compatibility. They will not void your warranty simply by being used, though Canon may try to claim otherwise. Choose reputable brands to avoid leaks or print quality issues.
Page yield varies by cartridge model and print density, but most compatible cartridges match or slightly exceed OEM page yield ratings. Standard capacity cartridges typically yield 180 to 300 pages for color and 200 to 400 pages for black ink, while XL versions can deliver two to three times those figures.
More to explore
5 Best Company Profile Examples 2026 | Templates That Win Clients
5 Best Custom Sticker Printing Services of 2026 | Die-Cut, Kiss-Cut, or Sheet
5 Best Cubicle Accessories of 2026 | Practical Upgrades for Your Desk
5 Best Contactless Business Cards 2026 | Top NFC & Digital Picks
5 Best Custom Book Printing Tools and Services of 2026 | Self-Publish Like a Pro
5 Best Custom Planners of 2026 | Your Schedule, Your System, Your Way
5 Best Tools for Current Writers of 2026 | Craft Books & Writing Accessories
