HP LaserJet printers are some of the most widely sold laser printers in the world, and HP’s OEM toner is among the most expensive per page. Compatible HP toner cartridges from quality third-party manufacturers close that cost gap significantly while maintaining the sharp, smear-resistant output that laser printing is known for. The five picks below cover the most popular HP laser printer cartridge numbers in 2026.
| Product | Best For | Rating |
|---|---|---|
| LD Products HP 58X High-Yield Compatible | HP LaserJet Pro M404/M428 | 4.7/5 |
| Valuetoner HP 85A Compatible | HP LaserJet P1102/M1212 | 4.6/5 |
| LINKYO HP 05A Compatible | HP LaserJet P2035/P2055 | 4.5/5 |
| CompAndSave HP 83A High-Yield | HP LaserJet Pro M201/M225 | 4.4/5 |
| Greencycle HP 78A Compatible | HP LaserJet P1606/M1536 | 4.2/5 |
LD Products HP 58X High-Yield Compatible - Best for Current HP Models
The HP CF258X (58X) is the go-to cartridge for the HP LaserJet Pro M404dn, M404dw, M404n, and MFP M428fdn. LD Products’ compatible version delivers the full 10,000-page rated yield, which makes the per-page cost exceptionally low even compared to other compatible options. Text and line graphic output is sharp and consistent throughout the cartridge’s life. LD Products ships their 58X with a chip designed to pass HP firmware security checks, and their team pushes updated chip versions when HP releases firmware patches. The two-year guarantee with free replacement covers any defective unit, making this a dependable choice for professional or high-volume use.
Browse LD Products HP 58X compatible toner on Amazon
Valuetoner HP 85A Compatible - Best for HP LaserJet P1102 and M1212
The HP CE285A (85A) is one of the most widely used cartridges for entry-level HP laser printers including the P1102, P1102w, M1212nf, M1217nfw, and Pro P1100. Valuetoner’s compatible version delivers the rated 1,600-page yield with clean, readable output on all common paper types. The cartridge installs without printer errors and the chip communicates properly with HP firmware on the listed models. At it provides the same page yield as the OEM at about half the price. Valuetoner seals each unit individually to prevent moisture ingress, and the protective pull-tab makes installation clean and mess-free.
Browse Valuetoner HP 85A compatible toner on Amazon
LINKYO HP 05A Compatible - Best for HP P2035 and P2055 Series
The HP CE505A (05A) and CE505X (05X) are workhorses in the mid-range HP LaserJet P2035, P2035n, P2050, P2055d, P2055dn, and P2055x printer lineup. LINKYO’s compatible 05A delivers the rated 2,300-page standard yield, while their 05X high-yield version reaches 6,500 pages. Output quality is consistently sharp on contracts, reports, and high-volume document printing. LINKYO’s chip accuracy on these cartridges is particularly reliable, with accurate toner level reporting throughout the cartridge’s life. The packaging includes a detailed installation guide and gloves, and LINKYO offers a satisfaction guarantee with responsive customer support.
Browse LINKYO HP 05A compatible toner on Amazon
CompAndSave HP 83A High-Yield - Best for HP LaserJet Pro M201 and M225
The HP CF283A (83A) and CF283X (83X) are the standard and high-yield options for the HP LaserJet Pro M201dw, M225dn, M225dw, M125nw, and M127fw. CompAndSave’s high-yield compatible delivers approximately 2,200 pages versus 1,500 for the standard, and costs less thancurrent pricing. Print quality is clean and consistent, and the cartridge has been verified to work with the current HP firmware deployed on these models. CompAndSave includes a two-year product guarantee and their replacement policy is straightforward. For offices using the M225 MFP as their primary print, copy, and scan device, this compatible option provides excellent ongoing cost control.
Browse CompAndSave HP 83A high-yield compatible on Amazon
Greencycle HP 78A Compatible - Best for HP P1606 and M1536 Series
The HP CE278A (78A) fits HP LaserJet P1566, P1606dn, M1536dnf, and Pro P1600. Greencycle’s compatible 78A delivers the rated 2,100-page yield with consistent output quality. The toner formula produces clean black text and accurate halftone rendering on graphics. Greencycle is a good fit for environmentally conscious users, as their manufacturing process emphasizes reduced packaging waste and they offer a cartridge return program. For HP printers in this series, the Greencycle 78A represents a sound balance of price, print quality, and ecological responsibility.
Browse Greencycle HP 78A compatible toner on Amazon
How to Choose Compatible Toner Cartridges for HP
HP printers use cartridge numbers tied to specific product lines, and getting the wrong number means the cartridge will not physically fit or will trigger a compatibility error. Start with your exact HP printer model number, confirm the cartridge number from the existing cartridge or printer manual, then search for compatible versions by that exact cartridge number. HP has been more aggressive than other brands in pushing firmware updates to block third-party cartridges, so choosing a supplier who actively monitors and responds to HP firmware updates is more important here than with Brother or Canon. High-yield versions are almost always the better value for regular print volumes.
For more HP printer content, visit our best HP printers for home offices and best wireless laser printers. See how we evaluate products at /methodology.
Frequently asked questions
Will HP update my printer firmware to block compatible toner?+
HP has issued firmware updates in the past that blocked certain third-party cartridges. Reputable compatible toner suppliers like LD Products and Valuetoner monitor HP firmware changes and release updated chip versions accordingly. To reduce risk, disable automatic firmware updates on your HP printer and check the supplier's compatibility notes before purchasing. If an update does block a cartridge, the supplier should provide a replacement or refund.
What is the best compatible toner for the HP LaserJet Pro M404dn?+
The HP CF258A (58A) standard-yield or CF258X (58X) high-yield compatible cartridges from LD Products or Valuetoner are the top-rated options for the M404dn. The high-yield 58X delivers 10,000 pages versus 3,000 for the standard version, making it significantly more economical for offices with regular print volumes. Confirm chip compatibility with your current printer firmware version before ordering.