Buying a used car is one of the most consequential purchases most people make. Reliability data is the single most important factor — a used car that breaks down frequently costs far more in repairs and inconvenience than a slightly higher purchase price for a more dependable model. The five models below consistently rank at the top of Consumer Reports reliability surveys and owner satisfaction scores across multiple recent model years, making them safe used car choices for buyers across budgets.
| Model | Best For | Rating |
|---|---|---|
| Toyota Camry (2020-2023) | Best all-around reliability | 9.4/10 |
| Honda Accord (2019-2023) | Driving dynamics + reliability | 9.2/10 |
| Toyota RAV4 (2019-2022) | Family SUV dependability | 9.3/10 |
| Mazda3 (2019-2023) | Premium feel at lower price | 9.1/10 |
| Toyota Corolla (2019-2023) | Budget reliable commuter | 9.0/10 |
Toyota Camry (2020-2023) — Best Overall Reliability
The Toyota Camry is one of the most reliable used midsize sedans available. The 2020 to 2023 model years use a well-developed 2.5-liter four-cylinder or optional 3.5-liter V6 engine, both with a proven track record. Owner reports consistently show low problem rates across powertrain, electrical, and body integrity categories. The interior is comfortable and quiet for the segment, and Toyota’s widespread dealer and parts network means service is accessible anywhere in the country. The Hybrid variant adds excellent fuel economy without meaningful reliability trade-offs. Resale value is strong, which is both a pro (the car holds value) and a consideration for purchase price.
Honda Accord (2019-2023) — Best Driving Experience
The Honda Accord has earned a reputation as one of the best-driving midsize sedans, and the 2019 to 2023 generation combines that reputation with strong reliability scores. The 1.5-liter turbocharged four-cylinder is the most common powertrain and offers a good balance of fuel economy and responsive performance. The 2.0-liter turbo available in higher trims is particularly engaging to drive. Consumer Reports owner satisfaction for this generation is consistently high. The cabin is spacious for passengers and cargo, and Honda Sensing safety technology — automatic emergency braking, lane-keeping assist, adaptive cruise — is standard across most trim levels.
Toyota RAV4 (2019-2022) — Best Reliable Family SUV
The fifth-generation RAV4 launched in 2019 and has maintained strong reliability ratings through the 2022 model year. It is one of the best-selling vehicles in the United States, which means used examples are widely available at competitive prices. The base 2.5-liter four-cylinder provides adequate power for most driving situations. The Hybrid variant is particularly strong for fuel economy and has a track record of reliable operation. Standard Toyota Safety Sense comes on most trim levels from this generation forward. Cargo space is competitive for the compact SUV segment, and rear passenger room is generous. AWD availability makes it a practical choice across climates.
Mazda3 (2019-2023) — Best Premium Feel
The Mazda3 occupies a unique position in the used car market: it offers a more refined interior, sharper steering, and a more European driving character than most competitors, often at a lower used price than a comparable Toyota or Honda. The 2019 redesign moved Mazda3 upscale significantly, with soft-touch materials and a quieter cabin. Reliability has been strong through the 2023 model year. The available turbocharged engine in higher trims provides noticeably spirited performance. Available as both a sedan and a hatchback, the hatchback body style offers added practicality. For buyers who want a car that feels more premium than its price suggests, the Mazda3 is the most compelling choice on this list.
Toyota Corolla (2019-2023) — Best Budget Reliable Commuter
The Toyota Corolla is the entry-level pick for buyers who prioritize long-term reliability and low cost of ownership over premium features. The 2019 redesign significantly improved the Corolla’s driving dynamics and interior quality from the previous generation. It is smaller and less powerful than the Camry, but for single or dual occupant commuting and light family use, it covers all the bases. Fuel economy in the mid-30s MPG range is strong. The hybrid variant extends that to the mid-50s. Used examples are widely available across price ranges, and Toyota’s reliability reputation applies fully. Parts are inexpensive and readily available, and most independent mechanics are very familiar with the powertrain.
How to Choose a Used Car
Consumer Reports recommends using model-specific reliability data rather than brand reputation alone when selecting a used car. A model that scores well in one generation may score poorly in a transition year with a new powertrain. Check the specific model year you are considering — not just the brand. Get a pre-purchase inspection from an independent mechanic before finalizing any used car purchase. Check the vehicle history report (Carfax or AutoCheck) for prior accidents, flood damage, and maintenance records. Factor in total cost of ownership including insurance, fuel, and typical maintenance costs, not just the purchase price. Finally, confirm that the trim level you are purchasing includes the safety features you want, as advanced driver assistance systems are often trim-specific.
For related automotive accessories, see our best compact battery charger guide and best compact amplifier roundup. Details on our review methodology are at methodology.
Frequently asked questions
What year used car is the best value according to Consumer Reports?+
Used cars that are two to four years old tend to offer the best value. They have depreciated from their original purchase price but are recent enough to have modern safety features and current-generation powertrains. Reliability data from Consumer Reports is also more available for recent model years, making it easier to identify models with strong records.
Which used cars have the lowest repair costs and best reliability?+
Toyota and Honda consistently top Consumer Reports reliability rankings. The Toyota Camry, Corolla, and RAV4 alongside the Honda Accord and Civic are among the most frequently cited reliable used car purchases. These models have well-documented service histories, widely available parts, and are familiar to most mechanics, which keeps labor costs manageable.