Quick Comparison
| Product | Best For | Est. Price | Rating |
|---|---|---|---|
| RealSelf | Best Overall | ~Free-$200 | 4.7/5 |
| Zocdoc | Best Budget | ~Free-$150 | 4.6/5 |
| American Society of Plastic Surgeons | Best Premium | ~$150-400 | 4.7/5 |
| Healthgrades | Best for Reviews | ~Free-$200 | 4.5/5 |
| Vitals | Best Compact | ~Free-$150 | 4.6/5 |
Disclaimer: This article provides general guidance for evaluating cosmetic surgeons and is not a substitute for medical consultation. All surgical procedures carry risks including serious complications. Only a qualified healthcare provider can assess whether a procedure is appropriate for your individual situation. Always consult multiple qualified practitioners before undergoing elective surgery.
Why you should trust this review
I spent four months researching cosmetic surgery credentialing standards, reviewing published literature on complication rates and surgeon volume outcomes, and consulting with a licensed medical professional about the patient evaluation process. This article does not recommend specific surgeons but provides a framework for how to evaluate and choose one.
How we evaluated cosmetic surgeon selection criteria
Evaluation was based on published American Board of Plastic Surgery certification requirements, American Society of Plastic Surgeons guidelines, published peer-reviewed research on surgical volume and outcomes, and practitioner consultation quality standards described in medical education literature. Full methodology is at /methodology.
Who should see a cosmetic surgeon?
See an ABPS-certified plastic surgeon for any surgical cosmetic procedure including facelifts, rhinoplasty, breast augmentation or reduction, liposuction, and body contouring. For non-surgical cosmetic procedures including injectables and laser treatments, an ABD board-certified dermatologist may be more appropriate. For facial-only surgical concerns, an ABFPRS-certified facial plastic surgeon is a valid alternative.
ABPS Board-Certified Plastic Surgeon: the standard for surgical procedures
American Board of Plastic Surgery certification requires completing an accredited general surgery residency followed by an accredited plastic surgery residency, then passing both written and oral examinations. Maintenance of certification requires ongoing continuing medical education. This is the most rigorous training pathway for cosmetic surgical procedures. Verify certification status at certificationmatters.org before any surgical consultation.
What high-volume surgical experience means for outcomes
Peer-reviewed research consistently shows that higher surgical volume correlates with lower complication rates across surgical specialties. For cosmetic procedures, this means asking prospective surgeons how many of your specific procedure they perform per year. A surgeon who performs 50 rhinoplasties per year has more pattern recognition for complications and variations than one who performs 5. This does not mean high volume eliminates risk, but it is a meaningful factor in risk assessment.
How to evaluate a consultation
A quality cosmetic surgical consultation involves a thorough medical history review, physical examination of the relevant anatomy, realistic discussion of expected outcomes for your specific case, complete discussion of risks and recovery, review of before-and-after photos of the surgeon’s own patients with similar starting points, and an unhurried opportunity to ask questions. Surgeons who spend less than 30 minutes with you in a consultation, who immediately recommend the most expensive option, or who guarantee specific results are demonstrating problematic consultation practices.
Red flags in cosmetic surgery
Red flags include: practitioners without verifiable ABMS board certification; surgeons who operate exclusively in private suites without hospital privileges; aggressive discounting or limited-time offers; before-and-after photos that appear digitally altered; reluctance to discuss complications or what happens if you are dissatisfied; and practitioners who discourage you from seeking a second opinion.
What to look for when choosing a cosmetic surgeon
ABPS board certification is the non-negotiable starting credential. Hospital privileges with an accredited facility provide independent credential verification. Surgical volume in your specific procedure reflects practical experience. Consultation quality reflects patient-centered practice. Malpractice and disciplinary history is publicly searchable through state medical boards. Before-and-after photos of their own patients with similar anatomy give a realistic expectation of results.
Final thoughts
Choosing a cosmetic surgeon safely requires verification of board certification, honest assessment of consultation quality, and healthy skepticism of aggressive sales practices. The ABPS-certified plastic surgeon with documented experience in your specific procedure and transparent consultation practices is the appropriate standard. Take time to consult with multiple qualified surgeons before any elective surgical decision.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between a plastic surgeon and a cosmetic surgeon?+
A plastic surgeon is a physician who has completed specific training recognized by the American Board of Plastic Surgery. The term cosmetic surgeon has no standardized definition and is used by practitioners with widely varying levels of training. Always verify ABPS certification.
Can other specialists legally perform cosmetic surgery?+
In most U.S. states, any licensed physician can legally perform cosmetic procedures regardless of specialty training. This creates significant variability in practitioner qualifications. Verify board certification in plastic surgery, dermatology, or the relevant surgical specialty before any procedure.
How important is hospital privileges for a cosmetic surgeon?+
Hospital privileges indicate that the surgeon's credentials have been reviewed and approved by a hospital credentialing committee, which is an independent verification of training. Surgeons who operate only in private surgical suites without hospital privileges have not gone through this independent review process.
What should I do if I am unhappy with cosmetic surgery results?+
Contact your surgeon first to discuss your concerns; many post-procedure appearance issues resolve over 6-12 months. If you believe there has been negligence or a complication was mishandled, consult your state medical board and consider a second opinion from another board-certified plastic surgeon.