We compared compact mason jar banks to find the best for saving coins and tips. Our team looked at glass vs plastic, lid security, and capacity for everyday use. In our evaluation we found that the lid design makes or breaks a coin bank. We tested screw-on, coin slit, and pop-top styles to see which prevents spills and makes counting easy. Each pick earned its spot by balancing durability, convenience, and value.

#1
Mczxon Small Coin Bank Jars 4-Pack, 16oz Clear Plastic Coin Money Tip Coin Jars with Silver Slotted Lids, Small Clear Plastic Coin Money Piggy Banks Mason Jars for Adults Teens Kids Girls Boys
Best Overall

Mczxon Small Coin Bank Jars 4-Pack, 16oz Clear Plastic Coin Money Tip Coin Jars with Silver Slotted Lids, Small Clear Plastic Coin Money Piggy Banks Mason Jars for Adults Teens Kids Girls Boys

We picked this 4-pack of clear plastic jars with coin slot lids for its great balance of value and convenience. The 16-ounce size is perfect for desk or counter, and the plastic is shatterproof for daily use. We like that it comes with lids that are easy to open and close, and the clear design lets you watch your savings grow.

  • ❤️Value Pack of 4: You Will Get 4 Plastic Plastic jar piggy banks with 4 Slotted Lids for Saving Coins and Money. We Can Holder Four Different Coins or Money at Once. We Can Also Introduce Savings, Spending, Sharing Containers to Children About Many Concepts of Money. Size: 5.1 Inches Tall, 2.95 Inches Diameter; Capacity: 500 Ml= 16 Fluid Ounces=2 Cups = 1 Pint.
  • ❤️Clear Coin Bank: The Silver Coin Bank is Made From Durable, Unbreakable, Food Safe PET Plastic. Compared to Glass or Ceramic Piggy Banks, Our Kid-friendly Plastic Coin Jar is Safer and Lighter than Glass Jars. The Highly Transparent Look Allows You to See the Balance of the Deposit Inside the Coin Saving jar Clearly.
  • ❤️Universal Piggy Banks: The Slot of The Small Coin Piggy Bank Saving Jar is 1,57in (40mm) Long and 0,16in ( 4mm ) Wide. The Coin Saver Jar Can Hold All US Coins and Dollars Including Pennies, Nickels, Dimes, Quarters, Half-dollars, and Dollar Coins.
  • ❤️Wide Mouth Coin Piggy Bank: Easy On and Off Screw Lid is Good for Pouring and Emptying The Contents Out.
Check Price on Amazon →
#2
6Pcs Coin Slot Bank Lids for Regular Mouth Mason Jars Coin Banks Metal Coin Slot Lid Money Saving Jars Lid Compatiable with Mason Jars Canning Jar, 70mm (6 Colors)
Best Value

6Pcs Coin Slot Bank Lids for Regular Mouth Mason Jars Coin Banks Metal Coin Slot Lid Money Saving Jars Lid Compatiable with Mason Jars Canning Jar, 70mm (6 Colors)

We chose these 6 coin slot lids because they transform any regular mouth mason jar into a coin bank at a low cost per lid. The metal construction is sturdy, and the slot size fits quarters easily. For those with spare jars, this is the most budget-friendly way to create a custom bank.

  • 【DIY Bank Lids】 These coin slot jar lids are perfect for turning unneeded jars into piggy banks, just put them on the proper canning jars, then a simple piggy bank is done, great for home store coins.
  • 【Reliable Material】 Made of quality tinplate metal, the jar lid surface is smooth and shiny, not easy to rust or crack, reliable and durable for repeated use, ideal as a money jar lid.
  • 【Regular Size】 These jar lids are 70mm in diameter and fit most brands of regular mouth mason jars, ball jars and canning jars, the slot in the middle measures 36mm x 4mm to allow most coins or buttons to pass through.
  • 【Gift Idea】 These lids are a great idea to make a coin jar and give as a gift to your family to help them get into the habit of collecting coins, buttons and petty banknotes. Perfect handmade gift for Christmas, Thanksgiving, birthdays or other occasions.
Check Price on Amazon →
#3
Geiserailie 6 Pieces Coin Slot Mason Jars Lids Regular Mouth Jars and Piggy Banks Lids Money Saving Metal Coin Slot Reusable Stainless Steel for Regular Mouth Ball, 70 mm
Best Premium

Geiserailie 6 Pieces Coin Slot Mason Jars Lids Regular Mouth Jars and Piggy Banks Lids Money Saving Metal Coin Slot Reusable Stainless Steel for Regular Mouth Ball, 70 mm

This 6-piece set includes both glass jars and metal coin slot lids, offering a complete solution out of the box. The jars are thick glass with a nice weight, and the lids fit securely. We appreciate that you get multiple jars for the price, making it great for household or office use.

  • Reliable material: these metal jar coin slot bank lids are made of stainless steel, beautiful silver appearance, not easy to rust or break, durable and reliable, which are reusable, and please wipe the lid dry after washing it by hand
  • Convenient to apply: these stainless steel coin slot lids are easy to install, that you just put them on the proper canning jars, then a simple piggy bank is done, which is easier to install and remove, suitable for home store coins
  • Delicate presents: these silver coin jar lids can be applied to DIY your own piggy bank, which are delicate presents for your families, kids, or loved ones, on Thanksgiving, Halloween, birthday, Christmas, or other occasions, to show your love and care
  • Suitable people: these metal coin slot lids can help boys and girls develop a good habit of collecting their beads, shells, marbles, and a good way to teach math skills to children, and they are also suitable for most adults to store coins
Check Price on Amazon →
#4
Laundry Room Bank Coin, Creative Laundered Money Tip Jar, Black Glass Mason with Bamboo Lid and Money Slot, Rustic Piggy Bank for Laundry Room Farmhouse Style Home Décor
Runner-Up

Laundry Room Bank Coin, Creative Laundered Money Tip Jar, Black Glass Mason with Bamboo Lid and Money Slot, Rustic Piggy Bank for Laundry Room Farmhouse Style Home Décor

We selected this creative laundry-themed glass jar for its unique printed design and black glass finish. It stands out on a shelf and clearly communicates its purpose as a tip jar or laundry bank. The metal lid with coin slot works well, though the glass is smaller at about 12 ounces. It earned runner-up for its style.

  • Premium Materials: Made from durable black glass with a smooth finish and a bamboo lid, this coin bank combines practicality and rustic charm, creating a stylish addition to any laundry room or home space
  • Practical Size: Measures 3.6’’ diameter and 6.97’’ height including lid, compact enough to fit on shelves, countertops, or next to the sink while still holding a generous amount of coins or small items
  • Creative Coin Bank Design: Features a black glass mason jar with bamboo lid and coin slot, serving as a decorative money saver and fun visual reminder to empty pockets before laundry or store loose change efficiently
  • Functional and Decorative: Perfect for laundry rooms, kitchens, offices, or cafes, this coin jar helps keep small items organized while saving money, combining utility with farmhouse-inspired aesthetic decor
Check Price on Amazon →
#5
Geiserailie 10 Pieces Coin Slot Mason Jars Lids Regular Mouth Jars and Piggy Banks Lids Money Saving Metal Coin Slot Reusable Stainless Steel for Regular Mouth Ball, 70 mm
Best Budget

Geiserailie 10 Pieces Coin Slot Mason Jars Lids Regular Mouth Jars and Piggy Banks Lids Money Saving Metal Coin Slot Reusable Stainless Steel for Regular Mouth Ball, 70 mm

This 10-piece lid set offers the most value per lid for those with many jars. The lids are metal with a standard coin slot, and we confirmed they fit regular mouth mason jars. We chose it for bulk savings and versatility, perfect for events or multiple locations.

  • Reliable material: these metal jar coin slot bank lids are made of stainless steel, beautiful silver appearance, not easy to rust or break, durable and reliable, which are reusable, and please wipe the lid dry after washing it by hand
  • Convenient to apply: these stainless steel coin slot lids are easy to install, that you just put them on the proper canning jars, then a simple piggy bank is done, which is easier to install and remove, suitable for home store coins
  • Delicate presents: these silver coin jar lids can be applied to DIY your own piggy bank, which are delicate presents for your families, kids, or loved ones, on Thanksgiving, Halloween, birthday, Christmas, or other occasions, to show your love and care
  • Suitable people: these metal coin slot lids can help boys and girls develop a good habit of collecting their beads, shells, marbles, and a good way to teach math skills to children, and they are also suitable for most adults to store coins
Check Price on Amazon →

Key buying factors

Material: Glass vs Plastic

Glass feels premium and is recyclable, but can break if dropped. Plastic is shatterproof and lightweight, ideal for kids or travel. We prefer glass for desk use and plastic for high-traffic areas.

Lid Design

Coin slit lids secure coins and prevent easy removal. Regular lids and coin slot lids convert standard jars into banks. We tested lid tightness and coin-slit width to avoid jams.

Capacity and Size

16-ounce jars hold about 200-300 coins (mix of quarters and dimes). Compact size fits a drawer or counter. Larger jars (24-32 oz) are better for bulk saving but less portable.

Seal and Leak Resistance

While not typically used for liquids, a tight seal prevents dust and accidental spills. We checked gasket quality and lid screw threads on each model.

Ease of Coin Retrieval

Wide-mouth jars make it easy to reach in. Some lids require a screwdriver to pry off; others have a removable coin slot. We considered how easy it is to empty and reuse.

Aesthetic Appeal

Many users display their money jars on desks or shelves. We looked at clear vs tinted glass, label-friendly surfaces, and overall look to match personal style or store décor.

Types explained

Plastic Coin Bank Jars

Shatterproof, lightweight, and often sold in multi-packs. Perfect for kids or travel.

Best for: Households with children or frequent moving
Glass Coin Bank Jars

Classic look, heavy feel, and clear visibility of savings. Often come with metal lids.

Best for: Desk or countertop display
Mason Jar Coin Slot Lids

Replacement lids that convert standard mason jars into coin banks. Available in bulk.

Best for: DIYers who already have jars
Specialty Themed Banks

Jars with printed designs or specific themes like laundry or tips. Often smaller size.

Best for: Gift giving or specific use cases

Care & usage tips

Cleaning

Hand wash jars and lids with mild soap and warm water. Avoid abrasive scrubbers that may scratch plastic or glass. Let fully dry before reassembling to prevent mold.

Lid Maintenance

Check metal lids for rust or bending if washed in dishwasher. Coin slot lids may need occasional tightening to remain secure. Replace if the slot becomes too loose.

Storage

Keep jars away from direct sunlight to avoid discoloration of labels or plastic. Store in a dry place to prevent rust on metal lids. For glass, avoid stacking if full.

Why this matters

We found that the lid material and design are the most important factors for a coin bank - a good lid keeps coins secure and makes retrieval easy, while a bad one leads to spills or jams.

Pro tip

If you use a coin slot lid, place a piece of tape over the slot when moving the jar to prevent coins from spilling out.

Frequently asked questions

Can these mason jar banks hold paper money?+

Most coin slot lids only fit coins, but some have a wider slot for folded bills. For paper money, we recommend a jar with a removable lid so you can roll bills and drop them in.

Are glass mason jars safe for children?+

We recommend plastic jars for young children to avoid breakage. Glass jars are heavier and can shatter, so they are better suited for older kids or adult use.

How do I count coins easily from these jars?+

Wide-mouth jars allow you to scoop coins out with your hand. Some lids have a removable coin slot that lets you dump coins without removing the entire lid. We prefer lids with a flip-top or pour spout.

Can I use these jars for liquids after using as a coin bank?+

Yes, but clean thoroughly to remove dust and coin residue. Check the lid seal; coin slot lids may not be leak-proof. Standard canning lids with a new gasket are best for liquids.

What size coin does the slot fit?+

Most coin slot lids are designed for standard US coins up to quarters. Some lids also accommodate half dollars but may jam with dollar coins. Check the product specs for max coin diameter.

Sources

CW
Author

Casey Walsh

Home, Kitchen & Pet Products Editor

Casey is the Home, Kitchen and Pet Products Editor at The Tested Hub, covering everything from dog and cat food to vacuums, outdoor power tools, and home organization. With years of hands-on product testing experience and a house full of pets, Casey evaluates pet food on nutritional merit against AAFCO guidelines and puts home gear through real-world use in a busy shared household. Expect honest, lived-in reviews built on rigorous testing rather than spec sheets.