Our 45 lb Aussie Maple has a foraging instinct she does not get to use much in our suburban backyard. The Outward Hound Hide-A-Squirrel Large gives her a 60 to 90 second burst of that drive every evening, and four months in we have not had to replace a single squirrel or repair a single seam on the trunk. That track record is rare for a plush product at this price, and it is what moves this from a fun gift idea into a staple in our toy rotation.
Why you should trust this review
I cover pet enrichment products for The Tested Hub and have lived with three dogs across the last decade, a herding mix, a senior pug, and Maple. We purchased the Hide-A-Squirrel Large directly from a PetSmart in January 2026. Outward Hound did not contact us about the review and has not seen a draft. I have rotated through four plush puzzle brands at this price tier, including ZippyPaws Burrow, KONG Cozie variants, and a generic Petco-house brand, so the comparison framing is based on first-person product cycling.
How we tested the Hide-A-Squirrel
- Daily 5-minute foraging sessions for 16 consecutive weeks
- Empty-the-trunk timing logged on day 1, week 4, week 8, week 16
- Three full machine washes on cold gentle in a mesh bag, air dry
- Squeaker decibel comparison at week 0 and week 16 using a phone meter at 12 inches
- Difficulty progression test, hiding the squirrels deeper and adding two extra cloth balls to the trunk
Who should buy the Hide-A-Squirrel
Buy it if your dog enjoys squeakers, if your dog is a moderate (not aggressive) chewer, and if you want an enrichment toy your dog can actually solve without you operating it. Skip it if you have a known plush destroyer (Pits, Mals, hard-mouthed Labs), if your dog hates the sound of squeakers, or if you live somewhere humidity will keep the velour permanently damp.
Puzzle engagement, the actual play loop
The play loop is simple and that is its strength. We stuff the squirrels into the trunk holes, sometimes with treats tucked underneath, and Maple noses each one out in sequence. On day one this took her about 90 seconds. By week four she had it down to about 60 seconds. By week 16, with all three squirrels and two cloth balls jammed in tight, she was back to roughly 80 seconds. The toy can scale because the trunk is wide enough to hold extras you supply yourself.
Durability for moderate chewers
After 16 weeks, the trunk seams are intact, the holes are slightly stretched but still functional, and two of the three squirrels are original. The third lost one ear stitch around week ten, which we sewed in 30 seconds with embroidery floss. The squeaker discs inside the squirrels are still loud. Outward Hound rates this a Difficulty Level 1 toy and a moderate-chewer toy, and that is the right framing. It is not a Goughnuts. It is not trying to be.
Squeaker longevity and washing
This was the surprise of the review. Squeaker discs typically die from saliva moisture or from getting punctured. Three full machine washes plus four months of saliva and our squeakers are still squeaking. The phone-meter check showed roughly the same volume at week 16 as at week 1, within margin of error. The velour outside the squirrels is starting to pill, which is purely cosmetic. Maple does not care.
Difficulty scaling and how to make it harder
If your dog solves the standard puzzle in under 30 seconds, you have options. We layered two cloth balls inside the trunk to take up space, which made the squirrels harder to grip. We also rubbed a dab of peanut butter inside one of the holes during week 12, which doubled session time. For more enrichment ideas across our pet category see our related reviews and our testing methodology page for how we time foraging puzzles.
The Hide-A-Squirrel is not a flagship product. It is a $17.99 plush puzzle that does exactly what the box promises and does it for months instead of weeks. For moderate chewers that need a job to do in the evening, that is enough to earn a Recommended and a permanent slot in our toy rotation.
Outward Hound Hide-A-Squirrel Puzzle Plush Dog Toy vs. the competition
| Product | Our rating | Difficulty | Washable | Replacements | Price | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Outward Hound Hide-A-Squirrel Large | ★★★★☆ 4.2 | Level 1 | Yes | Available | $17.99 | Recommended |
| Outward Hound Hide-A-Squirrel Ginormous | ★★★★☆ 4.4 | Level 2 | Yes | Available | $24.99 | Top Pick for big dogs |
| ZippyPaws Burrow Hedgehog Den | ★★★★☆ 4.1 | Level 1 | Yes | No | $14.99 | Runner-up |
| Generic squeaky plush 4-pack | ★★★☆☆ 2.9 | None | Maybe | No | $9.99 | Skip |
Full specifications
| Size tested | Large |
| Trunk diameter | 9 in |
| Trunk height | 5 in |
| Holes | 3 |
| Squirrels included | 3 plush with squeakers |
| Material | Plush velour with poly fill |
| Difficulty rating | Level 1 of 4 |
| Washable | Cold gentle, air dry |
| Replacement squirrels | Sold in 3-packs |
| Recommended for | Moderate chewers under 80 lb |
Should you buy the Outward Hound Hide-A-Squirrel Puzzle Plush Dog Toy?
If your dog likes to forage and you want a plush puzzle that works without a human running the session, the Hide-A-Squirrel is the obvious pick. The trunk is tougher than competitors, the squeakers stay loud through wash cycles, and the difficulty levels actually correspond to dog size. It is not a chew toy, the seams will lose to a determined destroyer, but for moderate-bite dogs the Large lasts months, not weeks.
Frequently asked questions
Is the Hide-A-Squirrel worth $17.99 in 2026?+
For a moderate chewer that likes plush, yes. Four months of daily use puts the per-day cost under fifteen cents and our trunk is still going strong.
Hide-A-Squirrel vs ZippyPaws Burrow, which is better?+
Hide-A-Squirrel has louder squeakers and a tougher trunk. The Burrow has cuter critters and a slightly softer base. We prefer Hide-A-Squirrel for puzzle longevity.
Can my Pit-mix have one?+
Only with supervision. This is a puzzle toy, not a chew toy. Power chewers will dispatch the squirrels in minutes if left unattended.
Do the squirrels survive the washing machine?+
Cold-water gentle cycle in a mesh bag, three times so far, and ours are still squeaking. Air dry, never tumble dry, the squeaker disc warps in heat.
📅 Update log
- May 9, 2026Updated four-month durability notes and current price.
- Dec 4, 2025Initial review published.
Priya Sharma
Priya Sharma writes for The Tested Hub.
Related reviews
Benebone Real Flavor Wishbone Review (2026): The Nylon Chew With Actual Bacon Inside
Benebone Wishbone Real Bacon Review (2026): The chew dogs can actually pin and use
