Starrett 18-Piece Punch Set Review (2026): The Punch Set Machinists Buy Once
After 6 months of metalworking use, the Starrett 18-piece punch and chisel set is the precision punch set machinists buy once and use for decades.
Alex Patel
Senior Tech & Computing Editor
Published: Nov 12, 2025
Updated: May 9, 2026
8 min read
โ
Affiliate disclosure: The Tested Hub earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no additional cost to you. Read full disclosure โ
The bottom line The Starrett S229WB 18-Piece Punch and Chisel Set is the precision punch set machinists buy once and use for decades. The hardened tool steel construction holds an edge through years of use, the comprehensive 18-piece set covers center punches, prick punches, drift punches, taper punches, and chisels in all common sizes, the included hard plastic case organizes the punches efficiently, and the Starrett build quality is dramatically better than imported alternatives. The trade is real money for what is functionally a set of metal punches.
Value
At $129 the Starrett 18-piece punch set is the right precision punch set in 2026.
โถ Watch on YouTube
Third-party YouTube content. Watch directly on YouTube.
Starrett S229WB 18-Piece Punch and Chisel Set vs. the competition
Product
Our rating
Pieces
Material
Origin
Price
Verdict
Starrett 18-Piece Set
โ โ โ โ โ 4.7
18
Tool steel
USA
$129
Editor's Choice
Mayhew 17-Piece Pro Set
โ โ โ โ โ 4.7
17
Tool steel
USA
$99
Best USA Alternative
GearWrench 23-Piece
โ โ โ โ โ 4.5
23
Standard
Imported
$59
Best Budget
Generic punch set
โ โ โ โ โ 3.6
Variable
Variable
Variable
$29
Skip
Full specifications
Pieces
18
Includes
Center punches, prick punches, drift punches, taper punches, chisels
Material
Hardened tool steel
Case
Hard plastic with foam
Made in USA
Yes
Warranty
Lifetime against manufacturing defects
โ FINAL VERDICT
Should you buy the Starrett S229WB 18-Piece Punch and Chisel Set?
The Starrett S229WB 18-Piece Punch and Chisel Set is the precision punch set machinists buy once and use for decades. The hardened tool steel construction holds an edge through years of use, the comprehensive 18-piece set covers center punches, prick punches, drift punches, taper punches, and chisels in all common sizes, the included hard plastic case organizes the punches efficiently, and the Starrett build quality is dramatically better than imported alternatives. The trade is real money for what is functionally a set of metal punches.
Yes for serious metalworking. The Starrett brand and tool steel construction are dramatically better than imported alternatives. For occasional use, Mayhew Pro saves $30.