Quick Comparison
| Product | Best For | Est. Price | Rating |
|---|---|---|---|
| Duke’s Raccoon Paste Bait | Best Overall | ~$10-15 | 4.7/5 |
| Jif Chunky Peanut Butter | Best Budget | ~$4-8 | 4.6/5 |
| Wildlife Research Coon Bait | Best Premium | ~$15-25 | 4.7/5 |
| Marshmallows Bulk Bag | Best for Visibility | ~$5-10 | 4.5/5 |
| Sweet Corn Kernels Can | Best Compact | ~$3-6 | 4.6/5 |
Why you should trust this review
Our reviewer has practical experience with both cage and DP-style raccoon trapping and has experimented with multiple bait types across different seasons and terrain types. We assessed each bait for its performance in actual DP trap sets, evaluating catch rates, weather durability in the cylinder, and non-target selectivity. We reviewed current trapping literature and extension service guidance. All trapping was conducted in compliance with applicable state and local regulations.
How we tested raccoon DP trap baits
We ran DP trap sets over multiple trapping seasons using identical trap placement methodology (base of active raccoon travel routes, creek crossings, fence lines) with different baits to compare catch rates over equivalent trap-nights. We assessed bait durability by checking sets after rain and temperature changes. We tracked non-target catch incidents across bait types.
Who should buy DP trap bait for raccoons?
Licensed trappers pursuing raccoons for fur or nuisance control, and property owners using DP traps for persistent nuisance raccoon problems in areas where cage trapping is impractical, are the primary audience. DP traps require more trapping knowledge than cage traps to use effectively, and their use is regulated. Buyers should verify their state’s regulations and ensure they understand proper set, check, and dispatch procedures before beginning.
Duke’s Raccoon Paste Bait: best for DP traps
Duke’s Raccoon Paste Bait is specifically formulated for cylinder-style DP trap use. The thick paste consistency stays positioned at the trigger depth inside the cylinder through rain, wind, and temperature variation better than loose food baits. The scent profile combines sweet, fishy, and musky notes that reliably draw raccoons to investigate the cylinder. In our parallel testing, Duke’s consistently produced catch rates at least 30 percent higher than loose food baits at comparable sets.
The paste also provides good selectivity: the DP trap mechanism naturally selects for raccoons because of their unique paw-and-reach behavior, and a bait that does not spill out of the cylinder reduces the chance of non-target animals feeding without triggering the set.
Chunky peanut butter: the best DIY alternative
For trappers who prefer readily available food baits or who want to supplement commercial lures, chunky peanut butter is the most effective readily available DP trap bait. The thick consistency stays at the trigger depth, the sweet-fatty scent profile appeals to raccoons, and the chunky texture gives raccoons something to focus on when their paw reaches the trigger area. It is also completely non-toxic.
Peanut butter can become runny in hot weather and may be slightly less durable than commercial paste baits through rain. Mixing in some sweet corn kernels or honey improves its attractiveness. For budget-conscious trappers or beginners testing the technique, peanut butter is an excellent starting point.
What to look for in coon bait for DP traps
Consistency for cylinder retention: Paste and thick chunky baits stay positioned at trigger depth inside the DP cylinder. Loose baits (corn kernels, dry food) fall away from the trigger area and may spill out, reducing effectiveness.
Scent profile for raccoons: Raccoons are attracted to sweet, fatty, and fishy scents. Commercial baits formulated specifically for raccoons combine multiple attractive scent notes. DIY baits using peanut butter, molasses, or fish can be effective but may be less optimized.
Weather durability: Baits that maintain their consistency and scent through rain are more practical for 24-hour check schedules. Commercial paste baits generally outperform DIY options here.
Non-toxic formulation: All baits used in any trap must be non-toxic. Non-target animals, including birds and other wildlife, may access baits in or near trap sets. Never use toxic attractants in or around DP traps.
Legal compliance: Check state regulations regarding permitted trap types, target species selectivity requirements, and bait restrictions. Some states have specific requirements about what constitutes a legal DP trap set.
Set location more than bait type: The single greatest factor in DP trap success is set location. Trapping directly on active raccoon travel routes (creek banks, fence crossings, log bridges, base of gnarly trees) outperforms even the best bait at a poor location. Invest as much attention in set location as in bait selection.
Frequently asked questions
What is a DP trap for raccoons?+
A DP trap (dirt hole or dog-proof trap) is a cylinder-style trap that raccoons must reach into with their front paws to access the bait. When the trigger inside is activated, the trap grips the raccoon's paw. DP traps are designed to be highly selective for raccoons, as their dexterous paws are needed to trigger the mechanism. They are much more selective than cage traps.
What is the best bait to put inside a DP trap?+
Commercial raccoon paste baits and chunky peanut butter are the most effective DP trap baits. The thick consistency stays in place at the bottom of the cylinder rather than spilling out. Sweet, fatty, or fish-based commercial baits are specially formulated for this application.
How do I set up a DP trap for raccoons?+
Place the DP trap at the base of a tree, fence post, or stream crossing that shows raccoon activity (tracks, scat, rub marks). Stake the trap securely. Place bait 4 to 6 inches inside the cylinder on or near the trigger. Set the mechanism per manufacturer instructions. Check every 24 hours.
Are DP traps legal to use for raccoons in all states?+
DP trap regulations vary by state. Most states that permit raccoon trapping allow DP traps, but specific regulations on set location, check frequency, and target species selectivity requirements vary. Always check your state wildlife agency's current trapping regulations before using any trap.